Mike Roberts - Thursday 18.09.14, 18:52pm
If it wasn’t so obvious, it would be funny.
Over the last four years I’ve lost count of the times that I’ve written that – with the occasional rare exception – clubs that have been relegated from the Premier League generally have no idea what to expect or how to prepare for the Championship. Cardiff (who should have probably known better) and Fulham have provided another couple of examples of this.
The best thing about this is that it fits the formula exactly:
* A change of ownership – in Fulham’s case, it’s basically jumping out of the frying pan into the fire.
* An appointment that doesn’t make sense (neither Solskjaer or Magath had any experience of managing in English football and were vanity appointments)
* A perception that the Championship is somehow ‘easier’ than the Premier League.
It’s very familiar isn’t it? I’m thinking Blackburn, Nottingham Forest and Leeds, but at least the penny seems to have dropped with Venky’s and the Hasawi family. I feel some sympathy for Solskjaer – who probably should have waited to try his luck at management in England and is young enough to have learned a valuable lesson about owners – but Magath clearly didn’t have a clue.
As I’ve exceeded my ‘two posts maximum per week’ rule, I’ll be back on Monday with a look at how the weekend turned out.
Mike Roberts - Monday 15.09.14, 18:52pm
Nottingham Forest stayed on top after a 1-1 draw with Derby yesterday (Rams defender Jake Buxton got the obligatory red card), but Norwich and Wolves kept up with the pace and remain one point behind the Tricky Trees. Norwich were generous enough to give Cardiff a two goal start in South Wales on Saturday before scoring four without reply, whilst Wolves must be kicking themselves for not winning at Bloomfield Road: if they had, they’d have gone to the top of the pile.
At the bottom, Blackpool and Fulham swapped places but neither side can escape the bottom three. After a goalless draw against Sheffield Wednesday on Saturday Bolton are three points from safety, but they’re already four points behind Birmingham and there’s a chance that the bottom four could be marooned by Saturday evening.
Some good games in prospect this midweek: tomorrow there are two matches that will have a direct impact at the top of the table.
Brentford v Norwich
Unbeaten at home, this is nosebleed time for the Bees: this is their highest league position since September 1952 and Saturday’s home win against Brighton was their first victory in the second tier at Griffin Park since May 1993, when they beat Barnsley 3-1. Buying Moses Odubajo and Andre Grey from Leyton Orient and Luton respectively looks like an incredibly shrewd piece of business by Mark Warburton.
As I mentioned above, Norwich came from behind at Cardiff on Saturday but they’ve not lost on their travels since August and they’re also currently reaping the benefits of a decent transfer policy. As he’s moved up the Football League, Lewis Grabban has scored goals at every level and his 22 for Bournemouth last season clearly didn’t go unnoticed at Carrow Road.
Last meeting in London: August 2009 in League One, which Brentford won 2-1. Before that, you’ve got to go back to September 1959, when Norwich won by the odd goal in seven. The Canaries had reached the semi finals of the FA Cup at the end of the previous season and went on to win promotion from the old Third Division in May 1960.
Charlton v Wolves
Four consecutive home wins is Charlton’s best streak at the Valley since the end of the 2012/13 season: since then, they’d struggled to win consecutive home games, let alone do this well. An early penalty from Yoni Buyens was enough to see off Watford on Saturday.
One thing that immediately jumps off the page about Wolves’ recent away form is how few goals there have been in their games since promotion. Apart from the recent goal fest against Blackburn at the end of last month, six of Wolves’ seven games since they arrived back in the Championship have featured one goal or less. They’ve failed to score in two of their three aways so far this season, but Charlton’s clean sheet last weekend was only their second at home since March. It looks like something has got to give.
On Wednesday it’s possible that one side could go into the weekend at the top and their opponents might be rooted to the bottom.
Nottingham Forest v Fulham
Forest were at it again at the weekend: they took the lead against Derby but had to settle for a draw. That happened eight times last season and was probably the main reason why they ended up outside the playoffs. Leon Best’s equaliser at the City Ground was the first time the opposition had scored against Forest this season.
I’ve no idea where to start with Fulham, other than suggesting that the outrageous fee spent on Ross McCormack has been a complete waste of money so far and could have been spent on a reasonably competent back four at this level. They’re probably due a win soon, but I doubt if it’ll happen on Wednesday: their last win at the City Ground – in fact, their last league game at Forest – was in September 2000.
I’ll be back at the weekend.
Mike Roberts - Friday 12.09.14, 11:11am
Before I continue, Chris Powell has returned to Championship management, being named as new gaffer at Huddersfield Town nine days ago. I thought Powell’s dismissal from Charlton earlier this year was rather harsh so I’d like to wish him all the best with the Terriers.
Watford replaced Beppe Sannino with Oscar Garcia, who was last seen around these parts after Brighton lost to Derby in last season’s playoffs. Having decided that Tel Aviv was too dangerous, Garcia returns to management in the more peaceful surroundings of south west Hertfordshire.
Looks like the bottom of the table will be where the movement is this weekend: five of the bottom six are at home (the exceptions are Fulham travel to Reading) and as I’ve decided to make Charlton v Watford the game of the week let’s look at the pair of games that almost made it…
Blackpool v Wolves
How to tell if the season is going to be a potential disaster: it’s the first game of September and even if Blackpool win they won’t be able to climb out of the bottom three. As well as six consecutive home defeats and no home win since March, the Tangerines haven’t scored more than once in a league game at Bloomfield Road since last November and have recorded only one victory in eight home games against Wolves from February 1971 onwards. There are plenty of rumours about Owen Coyle replacing Jose Riga, but you’d have to be pretty desperate for a job to consider the Blackpool job.
Wolves defensive prowess has continued from last season, but the defeat at Rotherham is still worth remembering before anyone gets carried away about back to back promotions. I think we’ll have a far better idea of how Kenny Jackett’s team are going to do by the end of this month, but they shouldn’t lose this one.
Ipswich v Millwall
I don’t think there’s any real reason for fans of the Tractor Boys to worry about their home form contributing to their slightly ropey start: the defeat against Norwich in the recent East Anglian derby was only their second league defeat at Portman Road since February. They’ve also beaten Millwall in four of their last six Championship encounters in Suffolk
As I wrote last week, Millwall have probably won games they’ve been expected to win so far, which means this one is probably their first reasonable challenge at home. That being said, the Lions are currently on a six game unbeaten away run, something they’ve not done for a couple of seasons: they looked like playoff contenders at that point until their league form collapsed whilst they enjoyed their run to the FA Cup semi finals. If they pick up all three points on Saturday then it’ll making Doubting Thomases like me take them more seriously as promotion contenders.
Game of the week: Charlton v Watford
This is the first in a sequence of three games this month that should determine whether the Addicks are long term promotion contenders. Charlton’s revival is an interesting one: they’ve won half of their last ten games at The Valley with two of their four losses in the period coming against teams no longer playing in the Championship – the other pair of defeats were against teams challenging (unsuccessfully as it turned out) for playoff places.
The revelation this season is Angolan striker Igor Vetokele, who arrived from Danish club Kobenhavn in the summer. The Championship player of the month for August has already scored as many goals as last season’s leading scorer (Marvin Sordell) managed in 2013/14, but Bob Peeters’ recruitment drive has seen experienced defenders Andre Bikey-Amougou and Tal Ben-Haim return from Greece and Belgium respectively whilst journeyman ‘keeper Stephen Henderson has also been added to the squad.
This is Watford’s second away game this season against a top six side and they lost 3-0 at Carrow Road last month, which is consistent with their performance in 2013/14. Last season the Hornets failed to beat any of the sides that finished above them on the road (compared to four wins in five games during the season they lost in the playoff final) and as I wrote last week I wonder if Beppe Sannino had seen the writing on the wall.
The Hornets are still more or less recognisable from the team that almost won promotion to the Premier League in 2013. Eight of the 19 players that have so far made at least one appearance in the Championship this season were at Vicarage Road during 2012/13. That group includes Troy Deeney and Fernando Forestieri as well as the returning Matej Vydra, who clearly isn’t good enough for either the Premier League or Serie A but is too expensive for Watford to sign permanently.
The fact that this is a playoff calibre squad makes Sannino’s decision to leave even more baffling. Perhaps he genuinely didn’t know what to do next.
Since the turn of the century, Charlton have only won one of the five games the clubs have played in the league in South London, which was the 3-1 win in April. Before that you’ve got to go back to August 1995 for the last Addicks home win.
A couple of televised games this weekend: Birmingham v Leeds (Sky Sports 1. 12:15pm) probably won’t be of any interest unless you support either team. The same could be said for Forest v Derby (Sunday, Sky Sports 1, 1:15pm) but this game has been a firecracker recently with at least one red card in four of the last five meetings and an excuse to sack the losing manager in both matches last season. The teams play each other at Derby in mid January and I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s game of the week.
I’ll be back on Monday with a look at the first Tuesday night programme of the season.
Mike Roberts - Friday 05.09.14, 14:57pm
Before I go any further, it’s time to say arrivederci to Beppe Sannino, who is no longer manager of Watford. The language used in his departure sounds remarkably similar to that used by Gianfranco Zola last December (a riff based on the old classic ‘I’ve taken the club as far as I can’) although there have also been rumours about a breakdown in his relationship with some players and a possible link up with another Championship club that already has a number of Italian connections.
Anyway, back to the monthly review. Some might argue that five games is hardly a big enough sample size to use when attempting to predict the rest of the season, but looking at the Championship table at the end of August over the last five seasons can certainly give some pointers.
From 31st August 2009 , on average at least one of the clubs in the top six at the end of August eventually won promotion, although last season all three of the sides that went up were in the top half dozen at the end of the month. It’s the same story at the bottom, but in three of the last five campaigns two clubs in the bottom six at the end of August have eventually been relegated.
Using widely available stats with some of my own methods, I’ve divided the current table into four categories based on how they’ve begun. However, it’s worth remembering the words of the old song ‘It’s not how you start, it’s how you finish’:
Nottingham Forest have begun well (undefeated and with the best goal difference) but haven’t played any of the other sides in the current top nine – games against Derby (14th September) and at Millwall the following week should give us more of an indication of their long term prospects. Currently the most improved side in the competition, but given their recent history that may not last for much longer.
Sannino’s departure from Watford surprised many considering the Hornets are top scorers, but four of their five wins and eleven of their 13 goals so far have come against teams currently 17th or worse with the 3-0 defeat at Norwich arguably being result that they should be judged by so far. Watford were also dumped out of the Capital One Cup by a League One side, so it’s plausible that Sannino may have realised that Watford’s apparent success was a mirage.
Wolves: have already beaten two former Premier League teams and one of the pre-season favourites for promotion at Molineux and might be set to repeat the recent feats of Southampton and Norwich by winning consecutive promotions. Norwich are the only club to have played more than once against the other sides currently in the top six, but haven’t lost since at defeat at Wolves on the opening weekend.
Like Watford, Millwall have benefitted from what looks suspiciously like an easy start to the season. Three of their wins have come against clubs that are currently eighteenth or worse and so although I’d be surprised if this form continues, they’re clearly better than they were in 2013/14. If they’re in the top six at the end of this month, I might have to start thinking about revising my initial prognosis.
Charlton are unbeaten after a good start but have a very tough looking September schedule (Watford, Wolves and Norwich) that might sort them out but it probably shouldn’t come as much of a surprise that Derby are not quite as good as they were last season. Despite only losing once so far, it’s possible that the goals may be slightly more difficult for the Rams to come by this season. Sheffield Wednesday haven’t won at home yet but have already won half as many away games in 2014/15 as they did in total last season. Cardiff and Brentford have yet to be tested.
If you look at the current table, there are eight clubs who have won twice but have lost at least twice: with the exception of newly promoted Rotherham (who have had a very tough start to the campaign), the rest are all underperforming compared to last season, with Middlesbrough playing at a substantially lower level. Both of Boro’s wins have come against teams in the bottom five, but three defeats against teams from the bottom half of the table indicate that the good form following Aitor Karanka’s appointment may be over. Blackburn clearly didn’t read my pre-season preview about improving their away defence.
Blackpool were widely tipped to be relegated before the season began and five straight defeats at the start of the season isn’t going to revise that opinion. However, in terms of pure regression Bolton are going backwards at a rate of knots whilst Huddersfield and – perhaps surprisingly – Ipswich are also in reverse gear. Birmingham City have improved slightly, but there wasn’t much to improve upon in the first place and the Blues are by no means out of the woods when it comes to relegation.
The big surprise at the bottom is Fulham. It’s possible to argue that they’ve had a baptism of fire at this level (three defeats in four games against sides in the top ten) but any team with a worse goal difference than Bolton isn’t going to finish in the top half of the table.
So there you have it. Back at the end of next week.
Mike Roberts - Thursday 28.08.14, 19:12pm
Quite a bit to get through this week, so we’ll start with the Capital One Cup.
After this week’s games, just under half of the clubs in the Championship are still in with a chance and we’ll come to them in a moment: Huddersfield, Rotherham, Watford, Millwall, Brentford, Charlton, Birmingham and Leeds will all be concentrating on the league until January and with five of those sides currently in the bottom half of the table I don’t think it’s unfair to suggest that is probably for the best. The Millers, Lions and Birmingham all lost to Premier League opposition whilst Watford and Leeds capitulated to League One sides – the latter made a real mess of it against Bradford.
The third round draw means two guaranteed places in the fourth round, but it’s not been particularly kind for those clubs drawn against Premier League teams.
Premier League Opposition: Bolton (at Chelsea), Middlesbrough (at Liverpool), Sheffield Wednesday (at Manchester City), Nottingham Forest (at Spurs)
All Championship: Cardiff v Bournemouth and Derby v Reading
League One Opposition: Fulham v Doncaster (who beat Watford), Norwich (at Shrewsbury)
League Two Opposition: Brighton (at Burton Albion)
Returning to the bread and butter, only Forest, Charlton and Sheffield Wednesday are undefeated so far and in one of those rare moments where all the planets align, game of the week features two of those sides and – even more remarkably – is televised.
Sheffield Wednesday v Nottingham Forest (Sky Sports 1, 12:00pm)
I’d imagine that Wednesday fans would be pleased with their start this season, but will probably remember that they were in exactly the same position two years ago but were in the bottom four by the end of September. The club’s current position is very deceptive: they’ve not won at home since the end of March (three draws and three defeats since) and although a goalless draw with Derby isn’t a bad result, Wednesday should have beaten Millwall a couple of weeks ago but a very late Magueye Gaye equaliser meant they only earned a point.
Since September 2000 Forest have won four of their last seven trips to Hillsborough but they’ve not won consecutive away games in the same season since March 2013 and have already had to come from behind at Bournemouth and Bolton so far. They’ve also been very inconsistent on the road over the last year: six wins in 23 games in the competition doesn’t really indicate that Forest are the type of team to win automatic promotion, especially as they’ve lost half of their last ten league games away from the City Ground.
Ir should be an interesting game, but I’d not be too shocked if it ended all square.
There are two other matches to keep an eye on:
Leeds United v Bolton Wanderers
Leeds beat Bolton at Elland Road on New Year’s Day 2013 but have lost half of the last six meetings between them in Yorkshire in the league and have only been victorious in three Championship games in front of their own fans since March. Given the nonsense with Brian McDermott last season, it should have come as no surprise that Dave Hockaday was apparently sacked and reinstated after last weekend’s thumping at Vicarage Road; I’ll be surprised if he makes it to Christmas (update: Hockaday lasted until Thursday evening)
Bolton got their act together away from home after Valentine’s Day, but although three defeats in their first four games has seen them drop into the bottom three, poor starts have been a speciality since Wanderers were relegated from the Premier League. They’re not the best team in the Championship and although they’re less dysfunctional than Leeds right now, anything could happen in this one.
Watford v Huddersfield Town
One home defeat in their last dozen home games bodes well for the Hornets this weekend, but since the turn of the century their record against Huddersfield at Vicarage Road is poor and includes a 4-1 defeat the last time these sides met back in May. The Terriers have improved since Mark Robbins left, but have only kept four away clean sheets in the Championship in the past year and will be hard pressed to add a fifth on Saturday.
It’s the first of the international weekends next week so there’ll more than likely be a recap next week with an overview of how the competition might develop.